Academics, officials, writers, and clergy we think can answer the f**king question. Four rotate onto the home page every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday — this is the full archive.
Four rotate onto the home page Mon · Wed · Fri· Vote for who you want on the mic — Vic sees the leaderboard every Sunday
ScienceIn rotation
John M. Martinis
Professor of Physics; Co-founder & CTO, Qolab · University of California, Santa Barbara; Qolab
Martinis won the 2025 Nobel Prize in Physics for demonstrating that macroscopic electrical circuits obey quantum mechanics — the foundation of superconducting qubit computing. He now runs Qolab, a startup building toward a million-qubit device and explicitly framing itself as 'the Nvidia of quantum.' Despite his stature, he has appeared on small and mid-size independent podcasts including *The New Quantum Era*, *TechSurge*, and *Genius Born or Made* in 2025–2026, demonstrating genuine accessibility. His candor about hype vs. reality ('a lot of hype has a low chance to work') is exactly the empirical rigor ATFQ demands.
“You won the Nobel for proving quantum mechanics governs macroscopic circuits — can you walk a non-physicist through why that was considered impossible, and what it actually means for computing power in everyday terms?”
Philosopher-Theologian; Host, The Reluctant Theologian Podcast · University of Lucerne; Visiting Professor, Palm Beach Atlantic University; Docent of Dogmatics, University of Helsinki
Mullins holds a PhD from St Andrews, is a docent at Helsinki, and runs *The Reluctant Theologian Podcast* — described as 'rigorous discussions at the intersection of theology, philosophy, science, and culture' with 'a willingness to tackle controversial topics with intellectual rigor.' He recently gave the Swindell Lecture at Talbot School of Theology and has hosted William Lane Craig as a guest. His podcast format — which regularly features adversarial guests and cross-disciplinary critique — mirrors ATFQ's ethos, and his academic pedigree across multiple international institutions ensures he can defend his positions with evidence rather than assertion.
“You defend classical theism using analytic philosophy — what is the single strongest argument that a secular progressive, who rejects appeals to scripture entirely, cannot dismiss without abandoning their own epistemological standards?”
William P. Reynolds Professor of History · University of Notre Dame
Fernández-Armesto is a prolific Catholic intellectual whose politics are, in one observer's words, 'hard to pin down' — which means Vic cannot pre-script the friction. He has appeared on the unSILOed podcast, The Burning Archive (two-part interview), and multiple YouTube history channels, showing a track record of engaging lay-audience interviewers. His recent Oxford History of the World (2024) and work challenging secular progressive assumptions about civilizational progress make him a live intellectual adversary, not a straw man.
“You've argued that no civilization is objectively superior to another — but doesn't that relativism undercut the progressive project of calling certain practices (slavery, theocracy, patriarchy) genuinely wrong? Can moral relativism and moral progress coexist?”
Senior Fellow & Director, Pronatalism Initiative · Institute for Family Studies / Cardus / Demographic Intelligence
Stone holds a PhD in Sociology from McGill and published peer-reviewed research in 2025 on Amish and Ultra-Orthodox fertility. He argued on Macro Musings (March 2025) that secularization is 'definitely a big part of the story' in fertility collapse, and has debated these themes across Mercatus, Cardus, AEI, and independent podcasts. He is a prolific, combative interviewee who corrects economists in real time and brings empirical receipts — exactly the adversarial profile Vic responds well to based on approved guests like McConnell and Cohen.
“Your data show religious people have significantly higher fertility — but correlation isn't causation. Couldn't that be explained by socioeconomic conservatism and community social pressure rather than faith itself?”
Professor of Physics; Director, Wisconsin IceCube Particle Astrophysics Center; Senior Scientist (former Head), Fermilab Theoretical Astrophysics Group · University of Wisconsin–Madison / Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory / University of Chicago (Kavli Institute)
Hooper is one of America's most accessible working physicists: he hosts *Why This Universe?* (116 episodes, 2020–2026, 10k–50k monthly listeners), has authored multiple public-facing books on dark matter and cosmology, and his recent research sits at the frontier of Standard Model failures — exactly the kind of paradigm-challenging science ATFQ targets. His podcast actively connects frontier physics to philosophy (consciousness, simulation arguments, the prospects for intelligent life), giving Vic multiple entry points for adversarial empirical dialogue. He is reachable via his UW-Madison faculty page and his podcast's public contact infrastructure.
“You've spent your career looking for dark matter and it keeps not showing up where our models predict. At what point does the absence of evidence become evidence that our fundamental framework is wrong — and what would that mean for physics as a discipline?”
Professor of Christian Ethics; Dean of Faculty, Talbot School of Theology · Talbot School of Theology, Biola University
Scott Rae is the longtime co-host of Biola's *Think Biblically* podcast, one of the most active Christian ethics voices in academic media, engaging weekly with contested cultural questions on abortion, bioethics, and moral philosophy. Unlike many theological guests, Rae consistently engages secular interlocutors on philosophical and empirical grounds rather than retreating to scripture-only arguments. He recently co-hosted a segment evaluating the ethics of capital punishment (October 2026) and has defended natural-law bioethics in peer-reviewed contexts — making him a disciplined, high-conviction sparring partner for Vic's secular moral framework.
“You ground human dignity in the imago Dei — but how do you make that argument persuasive to someone who doesn't accept the premise of God's existence? Is there a secular translation of your bioethics that holds up?”
Professor of Theology · Franciscan University of Steubenville
Bergsma is a former Dutch Reformed minister who converted to Catholicism after deep engagement with Old Testament scholarship, giving him cross-tradition credibility rare among Catholic academics. He appeared alongside Scott Hahn on the Franciscan University Presents podcast and has spoken publicly on the historical Adam debate — a topic at the exact intersection of ATFQ's Science and Religion pillars. His academic work is peer-reviewed, making him harder to dismiss than a popular apologist.
“You converted from Dutch Reformed Christianity to Catholicism through biblical scholarship — what specific textual or historical evidence moved you, and is that evidence available to a secular historian who doesn't already accept the faith?”
Professor of the Practice in Philosophy, McGrath Institute for Church Life · University of Notre Dame
Leading New Natural Law theorist on parental rights, subsidiarity and bioethics who applies her framework against both California and Texas. ATFQ tested the Motte-and-Bailey neutrality claim, the 1858 Mortara seizure and the Adoption Paradox.
“If genetic detachment is an intrinsic wrong in donor IVF, why is adoptive placement virtuous?”
McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence; Director, James Madison Program in American Ideals and Institutions · Princeton University
George is America's foremost natural-law theorist, author of 'In Defense of Natural Law' and 'Making Men Moral,' and a prolific cross-aisle debater who appeared on the New Yorker Radio Hour (Oct 2025), the Anchored Podcast alongside Cornel West (Dec 2025), and the Truth in the Public Square Podcast (Feb 2026). He has co-authored with Cornel West and publicly debated progressive scholars, making him willing and experienced at adversarial good-faith dialogue. His West Virginian working-class roots and self-described journey from FDR Democrat give Vic a genuine human entry point beyond pure ideology.
“You argue that natural law is accessible through reason alone — so if a secular host like me applies reason rigorously and reaches different conclusions on abortion or same-sex marriage, where exactly does your framework say I've gone wrong?”
Aziz Rana is a Harvard/Yale-educated constitutional law professor who ran for Congress in NY-19 with DSA endorsement in 2024 and is the author of 'The Constitutional Bind,' which argues that progressive reverence for the U.S. Constitution functions as a political trap that prevents structural reform. He appeared on DSA's national podcast discussing the current political terrain alongside Richie Floyd, and his willingness to name the constitutional system itself — not just bad actors within it — as the source of institutional failure makes him a uniquely blunt voice. His Boston College faculty page provides a direct contact route.
“Your book argues that progressive faith in the Constitution is a political trap. But every successful movement — abolition, labor, civil rights — eventually had to work through constitutional institutions. Where's the evidence that the trap can't be escaped from within?”
Emeritus Regius Professor of Moral and Pastoral Theology; Life Peer (Baron Biggar) · University of Oxford; House of Lords (Conservative)
Biggar is one of the English-speaking world's most combative public theologians, defending Christianity's role in liberal democracy and making a data-grounded case that colonial history is morally complex rather than straightforwardly condemnable — a position guaranteed to produce high-friction, evidence-driven dialogue with a progressive secular host. He has appeared on Unbelievable?, Winston Marshall Show, Quillette Cetera, Heretics with Andrew Gold, and smaller university podcasts, demonstrating comfort across the podcast spectrum. His 2025 elevation to the House of Lords adds live political relevance.
“You've argued that the British Empire had genuine moral achievements alongside its atrocities — but isn't that framing structurally designed to dilute accountability? How do you weigh institutional good against the lived suffering of colonized peoples?”
George C. Dix Professor in Constitutional Law; Senior Writer · Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law / Law & Liberty
McGinnis has argued that 'the rich play a very important sort of Madisonian counterbalance role' in democracy — a thesis tailor-made for Vic to push back on hard. He is the anchor constitutional law voice at Law & Liberty, has appeared on the Legal Talk Network and the Law & Liberty Podcast repeatedly, and writes regularly for National Review and City Journal, meaning he is fluent in adversarial public discourse without needing green-room coddling.
“You argue democracy 'needs the rich' as a Madisonian counterbalance — but doesn't that functionally enshrine oligarchy as a constitutional feature rather than a bug?”
Jonathan Blanchard Associate Professor of New Testament and Public Theology; Anglican Priest; Author; Podcast Host · Wheaton College (Litfin Divinity School) / Holy Post Media / The New York Times (contributing opinion writer)
McCaulley is an ordained Anglican priest, canon theologian, and evangelical New Testament scholar whose entire public project argues that Scripture — not secular liberalism — is the most coherent framework for racial justice, human dignity, and public ethics. His NYT columns and 'Reading While Black' explicitly defend Black ecclesial theology as an authoritative interpretive tradition, which would put him in direct, evidence-rich tension with Vic's secular progressivism. His Yale Center for Faith & Culture engagement and his own active podcast (100+ episodes) demonstrate he is fully capable of unscripted, adversarial dialogue without retreating to talking points.
“You've argued that Black ecclesial interpretation of Scripture is an authoritative framework for justice — but if the Bible has been used historically to justify slavery and segregation, why should a secular person accept any scripture-based epistemology as a reliable guide to what's right?”
Senior Research Fellow, AIER · Associate Director, Religious Liberty in the States (CRCD) · American Institute for Economic Research
Classical liberal economist, Adam Smith scholar and Fusionism advocate who breaks with populist orthodoxy on tariffs. Two sessions auditing the 2008 deregulation timeline, the 'Southern Paradox' of faith and outcomes, and who defines moral goods under Fusionism.
“If Fannie, Freddie and the CRA existed for decades, why did the crisis erupt in the 2000s alongside derivatives deregulation and Glass-Steagall repeal?”
Butler holds a PhD in quantum gravity from the University of Saskatchewan and uses hard physics to interrogate secular assumptions, making him unusually equipped to fight Vic on his own empirical turf. His 2023 Apologetics Canada conference talk framed AI and human identity through a Christian lens — asking whether humans are 'nothing more than a biological algorithm' — which maps directly onto ATFQ's Science and Philosophy pillars. As an active adjunct speaker bookable through Apologetics Canada's public speaker-request form, he is realistically reachable and has a demonstrated track record of engaging non-specialist audiences on contentious science-faith questions.
“You've spent years studying quantum gravity — a field where our best physical theories break down and no consensus exists. Doesn't that radical uncertainty at the foundation of physics actually undercut religious certainty rather than support it?”
Senior Pastor & Public Apologist · Grace Community Church / Give Me an Answer Ministry
Knechtle built his entire career on open-air, unscripted Q&A with hostile secular audiences on college campuses — his YouTube channel (Give Me an Answer) has 961K subscribers and 96M+ views, demonstrating sustained public appetite for his format. He debated Alex O'Connor (CosmicSkeptic) on the historicity of Matthew 27:52, showing willingness to engage credentialed secular skeptics on their own terms. His ministry model is explicitly adversarial-by-design, which maps directly onto ATFQ's core ethos.
“You've spent decades fielding hostile questions on college campuses. What's the single best secular objection to Christianity you've encountered — the one that actually gave you pause — and how did you resolve it?”
Executive Director, Church-State Council; Religious Liberty Attorney; Co-host, Just Liberty Podcast · Church-State Council (Seventh-day Adventist)
Reinach has been litigating religious liberty cases for nearly 40 years from the perspective of Seventh-day Adventists — a minority denomination historically concerned with state overreach — giving him a non-majority-Christian vantage point that separates him from typical culture-war guests. His podcast Just Liberty explicitly engages the argument that religious freedom has 'taken a PR hit' as a cover for bigotry, meaning he already engages the secular progressive critique directly. His dual role as practicing litigator and podcast co-host makes him an unusually bookable and media-fluent adversarial voice.
“You've spent 40 years litigating religious freedom from a minority-faith tradition. When does religious liberty become a tool of Christian majority power — and how would we even know when that line has been crossed?”
2nd Vice President, Henry County Democratic Women · Supervisor of Business Services, City of Stockbridge · City of Stockbridge, GA
Grassroots suburban Democratic organizing meets day-to-day municipal administration. Smith-Sellers sat down to defend Henry County's 65-point swing and answer why 450,000 eligible formerly incarcerated Georgians still don't know they can vote.
“Why hasn't a Democratic-led city like Stockbridge built a notification pipeline for the 450,000 Georgians whose voting rights were restored?”
Tocqueville Professor of Political Science & Concurrent Professor of Law; Founding Director, Center for Citizenship & Constitutional Government · University of Notre Dame
Muñoz's 2022 University of Chicago Press book Religious Liberty and the American Founding has been cited by Justice Alito and Chief Justice Roberts in Supreme Court church-state opinions, giving him rare direct policy impact. He appeared on ACTA's Higher Ed Now podcast in August 2026 and has a track record of small and mid-size audio appearances. His argument that progressive secularists have 'misread' the Founders to suppress religious expression is a direct adversarial challenge to Vic's framing of religion as a threat to democratic governance.
“Your scholarship has been cited by Justice Alito to restrict what government can compel religious organizations to do — but your originalism has real-world winners and losers. Who loses when your reading of the First Amendment wins in court?”
Professor of Philosophy · Honors Distinguished Faculty · DePaul University
Randian Objectivist, cosmopolitan and recent Christian convert who argues victimhood 'outsources your moral agency.' ATFQ put his own Title VII identity lawsuit, Johnson v. M'Intosh and his $120 bootstrap story under formal scrutiny.
“How do you condemn identity-based legal redress while suing DePaul under Title VII for race and sexual-orientation discrimination?”
Professor of Christian Apologetics · Talbot School of Theology, Biola University
McDowell co-hosts the Think Biblically podcast from Biola's Talbot School of Theology, one of the most active evangelical academic podcast platforms in the country, with episodes directly engaging secular ethics, AI, progressive politics, and scientific epistemology. He has published widely on apologetics and human sexuality and engages skeptics in live unscripted debate formats — including his Think Well Debate Series where he fields live challenges on God's existence and objective morality, exactly the high-friction format ATFQ needs. He is a tenure-track academic who also speaks to popular audiences, making him both credentialed and practiced at plain-language adversarial dialogue.
“You run live call-in debate sessions on whether God exists and whether objective morality requires God — have you ever had a caller who genuinely changed your mind on anything, or is the format performative rather than epistemically live?”
Professor of Church History & Philosophy; Chair, Dept. of Church History and Historical Theology · The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary
Wilsey's 2025 book 'Religious Freedom: A Conservative Primer' argues that the conservative and Biblical roots of religious freedom are being abandoned by both the secular left and the populist right — a position that opens multiple lines of adversarial conversation with a secular host. He has appeared on well over a dozen podcasts ranging from Law & Liberty and Thinking in Public to the Good Citizen Project and Clearly Reformed, demonstrating comfort with adversarial, intellectually demanding formats. As a Georgia native now at SBTS, he carries both regional resonance and national credibility.
“You argue that religious freedom has 'Biblical and conservative roots' — but isn't that framing itself a kind of Christian privilege that excludes non-believers from the founding story?”
Professor of Philosophy · Founding Director, PPE Program · Georgia State University
Prosocial libertarian grounded in Mill's harm principle, open immigration and civil discourse. Across two sessions ATFQ pressed the harm principle against a 1963 Southern town and a sole pharmacist refusing sickle-cell medication to Black residents.
“If one merchant refusing service isn't a dignitary harm but all of them is, where exactly does the harm principle draw the line?”
Independent Researcher & Speaker; MA Religious Studies candidate/graduate · Georgia State University (Religious Studies); Secular Student Alliance Speakers Bureau
Burnley is a Black former Christian who left organized religion and now researches the rapid rise of the religiously unaffiliated ('Nones') with specific focus on the African American community — a demographic and cultural story that is radically under-covered and directly relevant to ATFQ's Religion pillar around faith and public life under honest scrutiny. He has presented at the National AAR Annual Meeting, the Southeast Regional AAR, the Conference on Religious Trauma, and the Southeast Philosophy of Education Society, showing a track record of public academic engagement across multiple venues. His background in finance before academia adds a data-literacy credibility that matches ATFQ's data-driven inquiry ethos.
“Your research focuses on Black Americans leaving organized religion. What does the data actually show about the rate of that shift, and why is it being ignored by both the church and the press?”
Peachtree Professor of Evangelism and Church Growth; Senior Pastor, Wheat Street Baptist Church · Columbia Theological Seminary / Wheat Street Baptist Church
Watkins sits at the intersection of sociology, hip-hop culture, digital media, and faith — and he has the broadcast pedigree to prove it: his show on Atlanta Interfaith Broadcasting was the network's top-rated program for five years. His work explicitly challenges churches to engage the digital age and young adults rather than retreat into institutional insularity, which maps directly onto ATFQ's scrutiny of how faith operates in public life. As a Black pastor-scholar at a historically white Presbyterian seminary with a PhD in sociology, he models the kind of cross-institutional candor Vic values.
“You run a historically Black Baptist church while holding a chair at a historically white Presbyterian seminary — what does that dual institutional position reveal about how faith communities actually navigate racial and theological power?”